Urban transport in dire need of some miracle. There is a lack of
understanding of urban transportation and this coupled with limited data on various
transport modes across different towns and cities with great variance in their population
has led to ad-hoc planning to manage it which has further lead to chaos. Isolated
planning of physical infrastructure and transportation planning has become catalyst to the chaos. Traffic congestion, pollution- both
noise and air and lack of civic sense for driving along with insufficient and
expensive parking have been common problems that a rider faces.
Tremendous pressure on public transportation coupled with poor planning
and implementation has reduced the efficiency and effectiveness of the same to
carry passengers. Public transportation has always been a prime concern in India
due to poor physical infrastructure and support system. It is an easy observation
for any bystander to see people travelling in crowded buses and suburban trains
risking their lives by hanging out from the doors, travelling in crowded buses,
haggling over auto fare and quarrelling with the auto driver to take you to the
last mile and tampered meters is common in India. They are highly unreliable, inefficient,
unsafe, do not follow the timetable, damaged vehicles, un-coordinated and not integrated.
The drivers and conductors are not well trained and do not follow the traffic rules.
Public transport moreover in India usually runs in losses; the prime reason being
inefficiency- resulting in higher costs. Corruption too plays a major role in destroying
this transportation system.
With over 125 billion population where out of every 1000 people aged
above 15, 503 are employed and having an unemployment rate of 5%; there are enormous
numbers of people travelling every day. World Bank report suggests that over 520,464.78
thousand people belong to the labour force in India . These facts suggest that there
is a humungous number of people travelling regularly and there is a major need to
solve the public woes for traveling. Vehicle ownership in India too has significantly
increased to 178105732 in 2015. Due to this spike in the number of vehicle registration
in India and continuous addition of people to the labour force there is dire need
to improve the public transportation system in India which seems to be an overarched
target.
Taxis have hence proved to be quite a boon for people in India. Failure
of the governments to introduce a proper public transportation system created this
highly potential market for taxis. Having operating in India in various forms such
as Kaali-Peeli taxis, radio cabs, private taxis; they are largely unorganized. However,
with the advent of technology cab services are coming into the fold of organized
sector. Also, according to First Advance Estimates of National Income of Central
Statics Office per capita income in India is estimated to be more than a lakh. This
elucidates the increasing purchasing power of Indian citizens and the uplifting
lifestyle which make it suitable for the rise of cab aggregators to be the perfect
solution to resolve some of the issues for urban transportation.
With Uber and Ola, application based cab aggregators with maximum market
share in their segment, have recently gained a lot of attention in India. As of
2016 the taxi business in India is worth 13 to 15 billion of which 90% is still
in the unorganized sector. It is also expected that around half of this will move
to apps which is also supported by the fact that around Rs. 4000 crore business of car rentals went digital in the
two years prior to 2016. With funding of more than 15 billion US dollars the two
major taxi cab aggregators of India- Ola and Uber have transformed how people
in India travel. There are various reasons why cab aggregators like Ola and Uber
have been able to attract customers. Some of them are their availability of the
cabs, safety features incorporated like the SOS button and location sharing through
the mobile based application and transparent pricing model according to Khupse (2017).
Ola and Uber both are technology based aggregators and have similar
business plans, however some of their offering do differ. Both of them work on the
sharing principle and act as a mediator between the end consumer / rider and the
drivers. Initially they were just cab aggregators, though we have seen that they
have also included e-rickshaws, two-wheelers, auto and of recently cycles has also
been included on the Ola mobile platform. In fact Uber has also come up with its
own food delivery application called Uber Eat. In the Indian context there has been
a fierce competition between the two transport technology companies. On the global
level Uber is operation in 633 cities (Wikipedia- across 82 countries. While Ola
operates only in India but is present in 102 cities as against Uebr’s presence in 27 cities
according to its blog. However, Ola is still the market leader in India with a market
share of 65% as claimed by Economic
Times in its article published on May 1st, 2017
Now that both the companies are having a face-off, cab aggregator in
India are struggling to maintain and increase their market share in the taxi transportation
business in India. Ola is seen to have been spending a lot in trying to stay the
market leader but it has added to the financial woes and has suffered a consolidated
loss of Rs. 2,313.66 crores, the growth rate is now leaning on Uber’s side with
50% as compared to OLA’s 44.25% as stated by Medium (KalaGato) which is also mentioned
in an article published by Financial Express on July 27.
With the shift in the expectations of the investors from increase in
valuation of companies to cash benefits it is now becoming difficult for the companies
to maintain the confidence the investors have in them. These aggregators are now
should look for additional and other benefits they can provide to their customers.
Ola and Uber have already started doing so by diversifying their offerings. Ola,
for an example is piloting ‘Ola Pedal’ in IIT Kanpur for booking bicycles just
like you book cabs whereas Uber has joined the food ordering and delivery segment
with Uber Eats.
Let us now look at other possible models for cab aggregators to increase
their revenue and overall market share not only in the major metros and Tier I cities
but the Tier II cities as well. Someone has rightly said that a business is a solution
to a problem that exists in the market but with a difference. Cab aggregators can
too follow this idea and ensure a sustainable growth in their market share and revenue
in the tier II cities to add up the losses due to insufficient number of people
riding them to ensure operational profitability. Following are some of the
possible solutions:
1. Using cab space effectively by placing advertisements:
Though Ola and Uber- the two major
players in application based cab aggregators transportation solution service don’t
own any physical asset but they can use the cabs registered with them in an effective
way. One such usage of the physical asset can be using them for advertisement.
a.
The external space of the cars can be used for placing advertisements.
There can be two ways by which the cab aggregators could do so.
One, by outsourcing the job to a professional
outdoor advertising agency which operates at a national level or do the same at
a state level. The aggregators must make sure that they do provide customized service
for this because if they are able to convert the advertisements into sales for their
customers they can charge higher than other advertising agencies.
b.
Even the interior space can be used for placing advertisements.
One example could be placing magazines (like the one in the airplanes) and brochures
behind the front row seats which should be visible even if the customer does not
chose to take the brochure out to read it. However, it is also important to ensure
that the cab space is not cluttered or the entire exercise will go in vain.
2. Advertisements to increase the number of trips:
Ola
already has the physical infrastructure to implement this facility. Ola Play which
allows the users to entertain themselves while on the move can be used to reduce
the travel fare. The customers can be asked if they want to view advertisements
for benefits. The benefits can be in many forms such as:
a.
They can receive instant discount on their travel fare if they
agree to view advertisements while travelling. These advertisements will have to
be customized according to the needs of the user which can be tracked by tie ups
with Google and Facebook which are heavily invested in to data acquisition and analystics.
Hence the conversion rate from viewing advertisements to sales will be high.
b.
Another way can be offering coupons
for purchase from partner brands. This is another way where aggregators can charge
from the partner brands as well and save on the loss due to discount on the previous
method.
c.
Add travel miles to their account similar
to the flying miles offered by the airline companies. This way it can also be ensured
that customers remain loyal and can maintain their market share while trying to
increase it.
d.
Discounts can be given in form of cash
back to respective wallets like Ola play in case of Ola or the aggregators can partner
with other wallet services like Paytm, Google’s Tez or Mobikwik and earn from this
partnership as well. The cashbacks can be instant or delayed so that the money can
be used by the company as short term finances. Delayed cashback will effectively
nullify the cost of discount given if used as a short term source of finance.
In cab offerings where
facility like Ola Play is not available like the micro,
mini and auto services in Ola and
all services of other cab
aggregators the customer
can agree to watch
the advertisement on their smartphone itself. By doing
so cab aggregators can ensure
the above mentioned benefits for all without incurring extra cost
on setting up the infrastructure required.
3. Serving as same day courier service:
With the purchasing habits of consumers changing from visiting the stores to getting their daily needs delivered to their door
steps the need
of logistics has increased multifold. Cab aggregators could be of use
here as well.
The existing network
of cabs and bikes in their
fold could help solving the
same day courier
service. There could
be 3 ways to do so.
a.
One would follow the same mechanism
of cab sharing facility. The courier box to
be delivered would be treated
as a passenger and the person sending
or receiving the box could pay for the service. Since the cabs have a GPS facility
too, the movement of the boxes could be monitored on a real time basis.
However, some investment would
be needed to ensure the safety of the courier
and to cater special needs of the courier
sender; for example, if the goods
to be sent is fragile or brittle in nature.
b.
Second one
would work when
a rider books
for a non-sharing cab. In this case
the consumer can be given an option that
in case a courier service
is requested in the
same route would
the rider be fine with letting aggregator fulfil the request.
If the rider agrees
he can be given some
instant benefit and some additional offers as mentioned in point 2a to 2d if there is an actual request.The earnings here
could actually increase for the cab aggregator if the cost
of the benefits offered to the rider is less than the price
charged for the
courier service. The result of cheaper fares
would be increased demand and thus increase the revenues too specially
in the tier II cities
where the demand
for these cabs
are in lesser numbers.
c.
Third could
be launching an exclusive bike
courier service for same day couriers.
The software might
just need a little tweaking
but the aggregators would need to sign
up bikes on their platform
which won’t be a difficult task as the two majors have already started doing it.
The same day courier service
would also open a 2nd revenue stream
for the aggregators in form of
payments received from the stores and online platforms like BigBasket, Amazon, etc. Tie-ups could
also be engaged
with upcoming players
which need this service but lack resources to set their
logistic wing making
a win-win situation for all.
4. Utilize idle time of private
vehicles:
Most of the office going
people have their
vehicles parked at their office
places for atleast 8 hours. The vehicles
are also parked
in the garage
mostly during night
or when the
users of the car are not in town. Times
like these are being referred
to as idle time of private
vehicles. As it is vehicles
are a cost and not
an asset. The owners would
be more than happy to make money by converting
this cost to an asset by renting it out to cab aggregators. However, this
is not allowed
as per the laws of our nation
as private vehicles cannot run on commercial basis. The aggregators can lobby for
a change in policy and make the government allow
to start such service. This
would save the parking fee
paid by the owners
and would create
an additional source
of income for them as well.
5. Introduce
destination services:
Customized service
can be offered to riders in case they are travelling to places like airports, railway stations and bus stations. Majority of outdoor
travelling is either
for business purpose or tourism
which can be medical, pilgrimage, etc. Cab aggregators can act as a mediator between
the service providers
and the riders.
Aggregators can charge commission from the service
providers for providing
them with business. The riders can also
be given some benefits for choosing the services offered
by partner service
providers. Moreover, the experience of the riders
can be made hassle free.
For example, when a
rider is travelling to a railway station, the rider can be assisted
with his luggage
right from the time he gets off the cab to the train and then from getting
off the train to the hotel
where he booked his accommodation. Customers these days are as it is looking for convenience and this could
help the aggregators in maintaining customer
loyalty. Tie ups with porters, cloak rooms
and service providers like Oyo, Trivago
could be of use here.
6. Capitalize on Government’s push
for e-vehicles:
The minister for road transport and highways Mr.
Nitin Gadkari has
cleared the electric vehicle policy which
wants to make India a 100% electrically mobile nation by 2030. Cab aggregators could
make use of this and
push for waivers
by helping to contribute to this
plan by purchasing electric vehicles and help in creating the infrastructure like charging
stations which could
be used for free by the cab aggregator for
helping construct the
infra like the charging stations. They could
also take advantage of the nascent
stage of electric vehicles by asking for
favorable prices for
purchase and maintenance of the vehicles.
7.Specialized services: